Thrivent’s Statement

Update (12/20): The LCMS has issued a statement in response to Thrivent’s statement. Of particular note is this sentence by President Matthew Harrison: “However, the LCMS and every one of its entities and congregations are both pro-life and nonprofit, so we certainly hope that Thrivent will continue to support such pro-life, nonprofit organizations.”
Update 2 (12/20): A longer news article from the LCMS Reporter about the LCMS statement in response to Thrivent’s statement.

Original Post:
Thrivent has “temporarily” thrown the baby out with the bathwater. Let’s hope it’s very “temporarily”, indeed.

The corporation has posted a statement, responding to the controversy surrounding the inclusion of a Planned Parenthood affiliate in their Thrivent Choice program.

First the very good news: the Planned Parenthood affiliate has been removed, effective immediately.

“After input, discussion and a review of the concerns from Thrivent members, the leadership of this local chapter voted Thursday to remove it from the Thrivent Choice program effective immediately.”

Next, the not-so-good news: They’ve temporarily suspended all pro-life and pro-choice organizations from their Thrivent Choice program.

However, given that this second move is being done in addition to placing a temporary hold on any new organizations being added to the program, and a comprehensive review of the program, it may just be a necessary, momentary evil. (I truly hope that it is.)

I’m glad to see the comprehensive review, as the inclusion of a Planned Parenthood affiliate indicated a massive failure of oversight and moral direction in the Thrivent Choice program. Thrivent is “a faith-based, not-for-profit membership organization nearly 2.5 million members strong.” They are a Christian organization. A pro-life facility is in no way controversial in regards to that which guides the actions and life of a Christian, namely the word of God. Pro-choice organizations are in fact opposed to the clear, indisputable word of God.

Thrivent, as soon as you are able, please restore eligibility for pro-life organizations in Thrivent Choice. Permanently exclude any organization which describes itself, or operates, in fitting with your “pro-choice” label. Abortion is murder – fifth commandment stuff. It’s not fitting for a Christian organization to have its cash drawer open to those who advocate or commit murder without remorse.

Thrivent, I hope that the pro-life organizations that have been helped with Thrivent members’ Thrivent Choice funds aren’t now casualties of a misguided effort to honor so-called “diversity.” “Abhor what is evil; hold fast to what is good.” (Rom. 12:9)

Until then, Thrivent,  I imagine there will continue to be a massive outcry amongst the same Thrivent members who opposed your inclusion of Planned Parenthood at your exclusion now of faithful, helpful pro-life organizations.

In the meantime, I’ve asked Thrivent to provide some more information:

Previously:
Thrivent’s Dangerous Game
Thrivent Does Not Have the Komen “Out”